Then the messages began.
Starting almost immediately after Farver's disappearance, Kroupa received thousands of texts and emails from accounts claiming to be Farver. The messages were relentless and increasingly sinister. "I see you. You're sitting in your chair," one read. Others threatened violence, claimed she'd moved to Kansas, and taunted him with knowledge of his movements. Changing his phone number and email address made no difference. The harassment continued—between 25,000 and 50,000 messages over three years.
Farver's family and her son received similarly disturbing messages from her social media accounts. These cryptic posts seemed to prove Farver was alive, making investigation difficult. Police were slow to act, partly because Farver had a documented history of bipolar disorder. The narrative was convenient: a mentally unstable woman, perhaps staging her own disappearance.
But there were physical clues investigators couldn't ignore. In January 2013, Farver's Ford Explorer was discovered abandoned at Kroupa's apartment complex—in a different building than his unit. Inside was blood on the passenger seat cushion, hidden under a cover. A single fingerprint was lifted from the vehicle and later matched to Shanna Golyar, a woman who had been dating Kroupa on and off, and who had met Farver only once.
Golyar had her own story. In August 2013, her house caught fire under suspicious circumstances, killing four pets. She publicly blamed Farver, claiming the missing woman had set the blaze.
The breakthrough came from digital forensics. When investigators finally analyzed phone downloads from 2013—data that Kroupa and Golyar had voluntarily provided—the evidence was unmistakable. The downloaded records proved that Shanna Golyar had sent virtually all the harassing messages impersonating Farver. More damning still: phone records showed six blocked calls from Golyar's phone to Farver's residence in the days before the disappearance.
Golyar also demonstrated prior knowledge of Farver's vehicle location. The pieces of a deliberate, calculated murder fell into place.
On December 22, 2016—nearly four years after Farver's disappearance—Shanna Golyar was arrested. Her conviction followed, built on phone records, email metadata, fingerprints, and the digital trail of an impersonation campaign so elaborate it had fooled police and diverted suspicion for years.
Cari Farver's remains have never been recovered. But her case stands as a stark reminder that in the digital age, the evidence of our crimes often outlives our attempts to conceal them. What appeared to be the erratic behaviour of a missing woman was, in fact, the calculated harassment of a killer using her victim's own devices against those closest to her.
**Sources**
https://www.aetv.com/articles/cari-farver
https://charleyproject.org/case/cari-lea-farver
https://www.oxygen.com/a-plan-to-kill/crime-news/what-happened-to-cari-farver-how-she-was-killed-framed
https://truecrimesocietyblog.com/2025/10/20/the-murder-of-cari-farver/
https://www.botdpod.com/chapter-136-stalked-from-the-shadows-the-twisted-case-of-cari-farver-part-1/
