S-Town: An in-depth audio novel challenges true crime
Podcast
May 26, 2025 at 10:00 PM

S-Town: An in-depth audio novel challenges true crime

Vært
Susanne Sperling
Redaktør

John B McLemore and his journey in Shittown, Alabama

John B McLemore lives in Shittown, Alabama. With one simple email, McLemore sets out on a journey that takes the world by storm through the podcast S-Town. Created by the talented Brian Reed, in collaboration with Serial Productions and The New York Times Company, this podcast became an instant classic when it aired in March 2017. S-Town begins as an investigation into an alleged murder in Woodstock, Alabama, but evolves into a deep portrayal of McLemore's life and his internal struggles. He faces depression, attempts to come to terms with his sexuality, and experiences a world he sees as declining. All seven episodes were released simultaneously on platforms like Apple Podcasts and Spotify and were streamed over 100 million times globally due to its literary finesse and narrative complexity.

Ethical dilemmas and technical breakthroughs after a tragic twist

The story takes an unexpected turn when the alleged murder never occurs. Instead, listeners are drawn into McLemore's private world, where his battle with mental illness, understated homosexuality in a conservative society, and his passion for clocks and gardening come into focus. Everything reaches a climax when McLemore tragically commits suicide, forcing the podcast to raise sharp questions about ethical posthumous respect and the rights to a person's story. Criticism particularly targets the release of McLemore's suicide letter, leading to debates about journalistic ethics within the true crime genre. At the same time, technical breakthroughs are highlighted, like the 'binge-friendly' release model and the atmospheric sound that elegantly emphasizes Alabama's unique atmosphere.

Cultural debate's impact and the shift in podcast format

S-Town has shaped cultural debates and received the prestigious Peabody Award for its innovative narrative style, often referred to as 'an audio novel.' This podcast has highlighted mental health issues and LGBTQ+ challenges in rural areas while sparking discussions about workplace hazards like mercury poisoning from McLemore's work. Despite concerns from Woodstock about the negative portrayal of their town, the series has illuminated the area's social issues. S-Town has pushed the boundaries of the auditory medium and established a new paradigm for exploring personal stories through the true crime genre.

Listen to S-Town at podcasts.apple.com for an unforgettable journey into a man's life and the depths of the true crime world. Follow our magazine for more revealing analyses.

Susanne Sperling

Admin

Share this post: