How 'Willie the Actor' stole over $2 million and became the FBI's most wanted criminal
William Francis Sutton Jr., the man the FBI would eventually label one of America's most wanted criminals, was born on June 30, 1901, in Brooklyn, New York—a working-class Irish-American neighborhood where petty crime and street theft were common survival strategies for poor kids. By his teenage years, young Willie had already turned to theft. At 21, he was arrested on a murder charge but was acquitted. His first major prison sentence came in 1926–1927 for safecracking. Upon his release, Sutton turned his full attention to what would become his trademark: robbing banks.
What set Sutton apart from other bank robbers was his theatrical approach to crime. He earned the nickname "Willie the Actor" and "Slick Willie" for his ability to adopt sophisticated disguises and assume different roles. He posed as security guards, police officers, window cleaners, and messengers to gain access to bank vaults and secure areas. This method—blending into the environment rather than relying on violence—would define his criminal career.
On January 15, 1934, Sutton orchestrated one of his most infamous robberies: the Corn Exchange Bank and Trust in Philadelphia. He and his accomplices entered through a skylight, rounded up employees, handcuffed them, and confined them to a room before making off with the bank's cash. Later that year, he was apprehended and sentenced to 25 to 50 years in Eastern State Penitentiary in Philadelphia.
Geburt von Willie Sutton
William Francis Sutton Jr. wird in Brooklyn, New York geboren.
Erster Banküberfall
Sutton führt seinen ersten Banküberfall in Manhattan aus, verkleidet als Western-Union-Bote.
Gescheiterter Überfall in Philadelphia
Sutton versucht vergeblich, die Corn Exchange Bank and Trust Company als Postbote verkleidet auszurauben.
Erfolgreicher Einbruch
Sutton bricht mit zwei Komplizen durch ein Oberlicht in dieselbe Bank in Philadelphia ein – diesmal erfolgreich.
Spektakuläre Flucht
Sutton entkommt aus dem Holmesburg County Jail mit Hilfe von Waffen und gestohlenen Uniformen.
Letzte Verhaftung
Willie Sutton wird in Brooklyn von der Polizei verhaftet, nachdem Arnold Schuster ihn erkannt und verfolgt hat.
Veröffentlichung der Autobiografie
Suttons Buch 'I, Willie Sutton' erscheint, gemeinsam mit Quentin Reynolds verfasst.
Zweites Buch
Sutton veröffentlicht 'Where the Money Was' zusammen mit Edward Linn.
Tod von Willie Sutton
Willie Sutton stirbt im Alter von 79 Jahren.
But incarceration could not hold Sutton for long. Between 1932 and 1947, he executed at least three prison escapes. On December 11, 1932, he smuggled in a gun, held a guard hostage, and used a 45-foot ladder to scale a 30-foot prison wall. On April 3, 1945, he was among 12 convicts who tunneled out of Eastern State Penitentiary. Then on February 10, 1947, disguised as a prison guard and carrying a ladder, he walked out again.
For five years, Sutton lived as a fugitive, evading the FBI and law enforcement across the country. His criminal spree during this period was relentless. By his own estimate in his 1953 memoir *I, Willie Sutton*, he had stolen in excess of $2 million from more than 100 banks. On March 20, 1950, the FBI added his name to its "Ten Most Wanted List."
Sutton's freedom came to an abrupt end on February 5, 1952, when he was recognized on a Brooklyn subway by Arnold Schuster, a 24-year-old clothing salesman and amateur detective. Schuster called police, and Sutton was arrested. The capture seemed like a victory for law enforcement, and Schuster was even featured on television describing how he had helped apprehend one of America's most notorious criminals.
But Schuster's moment of glory came with a tragic cost. Albert Anastasia, boss of the Gambino crime family, reportedly took offense at Schuster's public finger-pointing. According to Mafia informant Joseph Valachi, Anastasia ordered Schuster's execution. On March 9, 1952—just over a month after Sutton's capture—Schuster was shot dead outside his home in Brooklyn.
After his 1952 arrest, Sutton was imprisoned in New York. He would eventually be released and lived out his remaining years in relative obscurity. Willie Sutton died on November 2, 1980, in Spring Hill, Florida, at the age of 79. He left behind a legacy as one of the most colorful and cunning criminals in American history—a man whose theatrical approach to bank robbery made him a folk legend, even as law enforcement pursued him relentlessly.