The Gardner Heist: America's Largest Art Theft in 1990

On March 18, 1990, two men disguised as police officers broke into the Isabella Stewart Gardner [Internal Link Placeholder] in Boston. They stole thirteen artworks, including Rembrandt's only seascape, "The Storm on the Sea of Galilee." This daring art heist, carried out in the early morning hours and with an estimated value of over $500 million, stands as the largest [Internal Link Placeholder] in U.S. history. After more than three decades, it remains an [Internal Link Placeholder] – an enigma that continues to plague the art world.

Rembrandt's 'Storm': The Art Before the Infamous Heist

Rembrandt van Rijn painted "The Storm on the Sea of Galilee" in 1633, at just 27 years old. The work demonstrates his masterful use of light and drama in depicting the biblical scene where Jesus calms the storm. The painting, measuring 160x128 cm, differed from his typical portraits and even included a discreet self-portrait of the artist among the struggling disciples. After several changes of ownership, it was acquired in 1898 by the flamboyant Boston art collector Isabella Stewart Gardner. She paid $6,000 for the masterpiece, which was given a prominent place in the Dutch Room of her personally designed [Internal Link Placeholder], alongside other priceless treasures such as Vermeer's "The Concert."

Gardner Heist Night: How the Art Theft Unfolded

On the night of March 18, 1990, at precisely 1:24 AM, the two fake police officers knocked on the [Internal Link Placeholder] side door. They claimed to be investigating a disturbance report. The two unsuspecting night guards, Richard Abath and Randy Hestand, let them in. The guards were quickly overpowered, handcuffed, and bound with duct tape. For the next 81 minutes, the thieves moved purposefully through the museum's galleries. With a brutality that shocked investigators, they cut paintings from their frames; "The Storm on the Sea of Galilee" was torn from its wooden stretcher. Limited [Internal Link Placeholder] from the museum's [Internal Link Placeholder] showed the thieves' systematic approach as they removed the thirteen works, which also included five drawings by Degas and a rare Rembrandt self-portrait.

Investigation Dead Ends: From Connor Jr. to Red Hook

The investigation faced a [Internal Link Placeholder] task with few [Internal Link Placeholder] clues from the [Internal Link Placeholder]. A fingerprint found on a glass was later linked to the notorious art thief Myles Connor Jr., although he was incarcerated at the time of the theft. Connor has since claimed to have information about the paintings' fate in exchange for immunity. DNA from electrical tape used to bind the guards pointed towards gangster Bobby Donati, but he was [Internal Link Placeholder] in 1991, effectively closing this potential line of investigation. A sensational, but ultimately fruitless, lead emerged in 1997. Journalist Tom Mashberg was led by art thief William Youngworth to a warehouse in Red Hook, Brooklyn. Mashberg caught a glimpse of a painting resembling the stolen Rembrandt, complete with a signature. However, a subsequent [Internal Link Placeholder] raid on the warehouse found nothing, only deepening the [Internal Link Placeholder] surrounding the missing artwork.

Empty Frames: The Gardner Heist's Enduring Impact

This extensive theft has had profound and lasting consequences. At the Isabella Stewart Gardner [Internal Link Placeholder], the empty frames still hang as a constant and painful reminder of the loss – a decision made to signal hope for the artworks' return. The museum's head of security, Anthony Amore, has dedicated much of his professional life to solving the case and recovering the art, and he maintains an unwavering optimism. For the two assaulted guards, Richard Abath and Randy Hestand, that night became a traumatic turning point. Abath, in particular, lived for years under a cloud of suspicion of complicity, although no [Internal Link Placeholder] was ever found to prove his guilt. The enduring public fascination with the case, often reaching [Internal Link Placeholder] levels, was most recently highlighted in March 2025, when a viral video showing [Internal Link Placeholder] agents seizing the Rembrandt painting turned out to be a PR stunt for a fictional [Internal Link Placeholder] about the Gardner heist, "Any Day Now."

$10 Million Question: Where is Rembrandt's Art Now?

Despite a $10 million reward offered by the [Internal Link Placeholder] – a significant sum of [Internal Link Placeholder] – and countless hours spent on the investigation, the fate of "The Storm on the Sea of Galilee" and the other twelve artworks remains one of art history's greatest unsolved mysteries. Speculation about this daring art heist ranges from the works being smuggled out of the U.S. via international criminal networks, to them being hidden in a private collection, or, in the worst-case scenario, destroyed. While Rembrandt's painted storm has long since subsided, the storm of unanswered questions and the nagging void left by the lost masterpieces continues with undiminished force in Boston's art world and far beyond, cementing the Gardner heist as a legendary case in true crime history.

Sources:

• people.com
• 1st-art-gallery.com
• mountauburn.org
• thecollector.com
• townandcountrymag.com

Follow KrimiNyt for more in-depth cases on daring heists, unsolved mysteries, and the dark side of art.