Paul føronczak: 55-year DNA Mystery and Stolen Lives
Paul Fronczak's 1964 Kidnapping: An Identity Mystery
One spring day in 1964, a woman disguised as a [Internal Link Placeholder] entered a [Internal Link Placeholder] room in Chicago and carried out one of the most sensational [Internal Link Placeholder] kidnappings in American history. But the story of Paul Fronczak is far more complex than a single crime. It spans six decades, revealing a web of misidentifications, genetic puzzles, and unsolved mysteries that still leave traces of hope and sorrow. Through [Internal Link Placeholder] and tireless investigation, the truth has slowly come to light, but each answer has led to new questions in a case that challenges our understanding of identity and family.
April 27, 1964: Fake Nurse and the Vanishing at Hospital
It was around noon on April 27, 1964, when 28-year-old Dora Fronczak was in her room at Michael Reese [Internal Link Placeholder] in Chicago. Her newborn son, Paul Joseph Fronczak, lay in her arms, only one day old. A woman in a [Internal Link Placeholder] uniform suddenly entered and announced that the infant needed a routine medical examination. Unsuspectingly, Dora handed her son over to the unknown woman – an act that would haunt her for the rest of her life. The fake nurse [Internal Link Placeholder] without a trace with Paul, and what followed became the largest search in Chicago's history. The police, assisted by [Internal Link Placeholder] agents, issued a detailed description of the perpetrator, while 175,000 [Internal Link Placeholder] workers distributed posters with the [Internal Link Placeholder] picture. But weeks passed, and no trace of the missing baby emerged.
The Miracle of 1965: Was the Found Child Really Paul?
Two years later, in July 1965, an approximately two-year-old child was found abandoned in a stroller outside a department store in Newark, [Internal Link Placeholder]. An observant police officer remembered an old newspaper photo of the missing Paul Fronczak and contacted authorities in Chicago. [Internal Link Placeholder] concluded that the child's ear shape and [Internal Link Placeholder] type matched, and despite the lack of [Internal Link Placeholder] at the time, the boy was declared to be the abducted Paul. For Dora and Chester Fronczak, it was a miracle. "It's my [Internal Link Placeholder], it's Paul!" Dora exclaimed. But the [Internal Link Placeholder] of this kidnapping was far from solved. Why had the kidnapper abandoned the child? And why were there no signs of [Internal Link Placeholder]? These questions were overshadowed by relief.
Paul Fronczak's Doubt: DNA Test Exposed Identity Theft
From an early age, however, doubt began to gnaw at the boy who grew up as Paul Fronczak. At age 10, he found a box of newspaper clippings about his own kidnapping. His mother refused to discuss it: "Yes, you were abducted, we found you, we love you, and that's all you need to know." This episode triggered a decades-long identity crisis. As an adult, Paul worked as a university administrator in [Internal Link Placeholder], but the lack of physical resemblance to his parents troubled him. In 2012, he took an at-home DNA test. The result was a shock: there was no biological connection to the Fronczak family. For Paul, the discovery meant he had lived for decades under an identity that was not his own, a form of involuntary [Internal Link Placeholder] imposed on him by circumstances.
The Hunt for Truth: Misidentified Paul Finds Real Name
After the DNA confirmation, Paul, now stripped of his previous identity, began a dual search: to find the real Paul Fronczak and to uncover his own mysterious background. With the help of renowned genetic genealogist CeCe Moore, he discovered his real name was Jack Rosenthal. He had been born six months before the abducted Paul, as a twin to a sister named Jill. Their biological parents, Gilbert and Marie Rosenthal, had abandoned him in [Internal Link Placeholder] in 1965 – the same year Jill disappeared. Investigations into the Rosenthal family revealed a dark history of [Internal Link Placeholder] and child maltreatment. According to family members, the twins had been subjected to [Internal Link Placeholder] and allegedly kept in a cage. While Jack was abandoned, Paul/Jack suspects Jill was [Internal Link Placeholder], although this remains an [Internal Link Placeholder].
2019 Breakthrough: Real Paul Fronczak Found as Kevin Baty
In 2019, a crucial breakthrough occurred. DNA tracing pointed to a man in [Internal Link Placeholder] as the real Paul Fronczak. He was living under the name Kevin Baty, raised by Robert and Lorraine Fountain. Baty, who was battling terminal cancer, confirmed through [Internal Link Placeholder] that he was the child kidnapped from Michael Reese [Internal Link Placeholder] in 1964. In a bittersweet turn of events, he managed to reconnect with his biological mother, Dora, before his death in 2020.
Unanswered Questions: Kidnapper's Fate and Jill's Whereabouts
Although Kevin's identity as the original Paul Fronczak has been confirmed, central questions in this complex kidnapping case remain open. Who was the fake [Internal Link Placeholder], and what was her motive? The [Internal Link Placeholder] has reopened this [Internal Link Placeholder] several times, most recently in 2013, but the kidnapper's identity is still unknown. Jill Rosenthal's fate is likewise a painful, unsolved [Internal Link Placeholder]. Paul/Jack has used ground-penetrating radar in an attempt to find her remains, without success.
Kidnapping's Legacy: Dora Fronczak's Loss and DNA's Role
The case's effects have impacted generations. Dora Fronczak experienced the unthinkable: losing her son twice. For Paul/Jack, the search for identity has been a life-altering journey, which he described in his book "The Foundling" and participated in the acclaimed documentary "The Lost Sons" (2021). The case underscores how [Internal Link Placeholder] and modern genetic genealogy, as used by CeCe Moore, have revolutionized the solving of cold cases and missing persons cases. Had today's methods existed in 1965, the tragic misidentification could have been avoided.
System Failure and Ethics: Hospital's Role and Challenges
The case has also cast a critical light on the handling by the justice system. Michael Reese [Internal Link Placeholder] was sued for negligence, resulting in a lawsuit that was settled out of court. The question of how a child could be so fatally misidentified has sparked debate and underscored the importance of accurate identification methods. Extensive [Internal Link Placeholder] coverage over the years has kept the case in the public eye. Paul/Jack's decision to use [Internal Link Placeholder] to uncover the truth raises ethical questions about the right to know versus family peace, just as the disclosure of Kevin Baty's identity sparked debate about victims' right to privacy.
Unfinished Search: FBI's Hunt and Paul/Jack's Quest for Jill
Although the [Internal Link Placeholder] of the abducted [Internal Link Placeholder] is partially solved, the search continues. The [Internal Link Placeholder] is still working to identify the kidnapper, while Paul/Jack dedicates his life to finding his twin sister, Jill. The documentary "The Lost Sons" depicts his emotional meeting with Kevin's family in [Internal Link Placeholder] and the unresolved grief. The story of Paul Fronczak is more than a criminal case; it is a profound human study of the search for belonging and identity. It shows how technology can solve old riddles but also open new wounds in an [Internal Link Placeholder] that continues to unfold.
Sources:
Do you want to read more stories about unsolved kidnappings, DNA breakthroughs, and identity mysteries? Follow KrimiNyt and never miss the next case.