True crime news logo
  • Krimidex

Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest stories

Never miss the latest true crime news, reviews and top lists — plus new podcasts, series, films and books.

You can unsubscribe with one click from any email.

True crime news logo

The international true crime destination. Cases, documentaries, podcasts and travel routes.

© 2026 truecrime.news. All rights reserved.

The Piketon Massacre: A Deeply Fateful Murder Mystery
Podcast
•
May 26, 2025 at 10:00 PM

The Pike County Massacre: Eight Deaths, One Family's Dark Secret

How a premeditated execution-style killing spree in rural Ohio became the state's largest murder investigation

About This Episode

ProduzentiHeartPodcasts
Episoden63
GenreTrue Crime
Letzte Episode12. April 2023

On the night of April 21–22, 2016, gunmen executed eight members of the Rhoden family across four homes in Sunfish Township, Pike County, Ohio—a rural area 50 miles from Columbus. The victims, ranging from a 16-year-old boy to adults, were shot in their beds, most in the head. Some received multiple gunshot wounds; the total tally across all victims: 32 gunshot wounds. Three young children, including two infants, were present in the homes but physically unharmed.

The eighth victim was found in a camper in nearby Piketon. All bodies were discovered on April 22, 2016, in what would become Ohio's largest criminal investigation, eventually involving more than two dozen agencies across 10 states and Canada.

**The Investigation**

Detectives quickly identified critical details pointing toward an inside job. The perpetrators knew the victims' daily routines, home layouts, and exact sleeping locations—knowledge that suggested meticulous planning rather than random violence. Evidence of marijuana cultivation and cockfighting operations at some scenes surfaced during the investigation, though no direct connection to the murders was confirmed.

The breakthrough came nearly three years after the murders: on November 13, 2018, authorities arrested four members of the Wagner family from South Webster, Ohio, a town near the Rhoden homes. Billy Wagner III (47), his wife Angela Wagner (48), their son George Wagner IV (27), and their younger son Edward "Jake" Wagner (26) were all charged with eight counts of aggravated murder with death penalty specifications.

The Wagners had been neighbors and acquaintances of the Rhodens before the killings—a detail that deepened the mystery surrounding their motives. Jake Wagner added another layer of complexity: he was the ex-boyfriend of victim Hanna Rhoden and the father of her three-year-old daughter.

Two additional arrests followed. Rita Newcomb (65), Angela Wagner's mother, and Fredericka Wagner (76), Billy Wagner's mother, were charged with obstructing justice, perjury, and forgery—suggesting the family's involvement extended beyond the perpetrators themselves. Evidence presented included a homemade firearm suppressor built by the suspects and signs of evidence tampering, including the removal or destruction of victims' phones and property.

**The Guilty Plea**

In a dramatic turn, Edward "Jake" Wagner pleaded guilty to all eight murders in 2021. He admitted to shooting five victims directly and shooting a sixth. In exchange for his cooperation, Jake Wagner avoided the death penalty and received a sentence of life in prison without parole.

His confession provided prosecutors with crucial insider testimony, but three family members—Billy, Angela, and George IV Wagner—continued to face capital murder charges. As of 2023, trials remained ongoing, with George Wagner IV's case still in proceedings according to recent podcast documentation.

**Lingering Questions**

While Jake Wagner's guilty plea resolved some questions, the full circumstances surrounding the family's motive remain partially unclear. Court documents suggest interpersonal conflict and disputes between the families, but the precise trigger for such a calculated, multi-family execution remains complex.

The case stands as a stark reminder that rural America's most brutal crimes often emerge from intimate community conflicts rather than random violence. The Pike County Massacre fundamentally changed how law enforcement approaches mass-casualty investigations in smaller jurisdictions, and the trials of the remaining Wagners continue to draw international attention to this rural Ohio tragedy.

**Sources**

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pike_County_shootings

https://www.ohioattorneygeneral.gov/Media/News-Releases/November-2018/Pike-County-Homicides-Family-Arrested

https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-piketon-massacre/id1700713500

https://open.spotify.com/show/2gAmmUUZhhFTkFRQ0IS5X9

About This Episode

ProduzentiHeartPodcasts
Episoden63
GenreTrue Crime
Letzte Episode12. April 2023
Related Content
The Murders at White House Farm reveals deep family secrets

White House Farm: The Murders That Divided a Family

Norwegian Crime Cases

Norske Krimsaker: Norway's Most Notorious Crimes on Screen

Family murder: shocking double murder revealed

Danish War Veteran Held Parents' Bodies in Car for a Week

Murder and Mysteries: Village Secrets

Mord og Mysterier: How Midsomer Murders Became a Norwegian Phenomenon

Advertisement
Del dette opslag: